Blog Header Image

Erik Schreiber

   •    

May 22, 2025

Is It the Coffee or the Habit? Why Your Morning Cup Hits Different

Is It the Coffee or the Ritual? Why Your Morning Cup Matters More Than You Think

Let’s be honest—there’s something sacred about that first cup of coffee in the morning. Whether it’s the warmth in your hands, the familiar smell, or the sense of “everything’s going to be okay now,” coffee means more to people than just caffeine.

And while caffeine has been misunderstood over the years, science tells a much more balanced story—one that includes mental clarity, performance benefits, and even longevity. So… is coffee good for you? Or is it just a comforting crutch? Let’s dive into the science, the ritual, and the psychology behind your daily brew.

Caffeine and Performance: What the Research Says

Caffeine is one of the most well-studied performance-enhancing substances in the world. According to the International Society of Sports Nutrition (ISSN):

"Caffeine is effective for enhancing several aspects of exercise performance, including muscular endurance, sprinting, jumping, and throwing performance, as well as a wide range of aerobic and anaerobic sport-specific actions."

Key proven benefits of caffeine:

  • Increased alertness and cognitive function
  • Reduced perceived effort during exercise
  • Improved muscular endurance and power output
  • Enhanced fat oxidation during aerobic activity

The optimal dose is often cited around 3–6 mg/kg of body weight, roughly 200–400 mg for most adults (about 1–3 cups of coffee), taken 30–60 minutes before training. So if you're reaching for coffee before a workout or a big meeting—you're not just imagining the benefit.

But What About the Ritual?

Here’s where it gets even more interesting. Beyond the pharmacological effects of caffeine, there’s a powerful behavioral psychology element at play: the ritual of drinking coffee.

Routines and rituals are known to:

  • Anchor your day
  • Reduce decision fatigue
  • Provide a sense of control and comfort
  • Prime your brain for focus and productivity

In other words, it’s not just the caffeine—it’s the context.

For many people, drinking coffee is a daily cue that says, “It’s time to start the day. I’ve got this.” You’re not imagining it when you say your mood shifts after your first sip. And yes—that shift is real, whether it’s driven by the chemical kick or the comforting routine.

What Happens When You Don’t Get It?

Ever seen someone forced to start their day without coffee? (I have. She’s married to me.)
And the truth is, they’re not faking it.

Caffeine withdrawal symptoms—recognized by the World Health Organization—include:

  • Irritability
  • Fatigue
  • Headaches
  • Brain fog
  • Decreased motivation

So no, it’s not “all in your head”—but the head definitely plays a role. Whether it's chemical dependence or behavioral attachment (or both), skipping your morning coffee can disrupt the rhythm and tone of your entire day.

So… Is Coffee Good or Bad?

Like most things in nutrition and wellness, context and moderation matter.

Coffee in moderation (2–4 cups/day) has been linked to:

  • Lower risk of Parkinson’s, Alzheimer’s, and Type 2 Diabetes
  • Improved cognitive performance
  • Potential cardiovascular benefits
  • Lower overall all-cause mortality (according to several large cohort studies)

But—too much caffeine (especially late in the day) can:

  • Disrupt sleep
  • Increase anxiety
  • Lead to digestive issues or dependency
  • Exacerbate stress in sensitive individuals

Final Thoughts: Coffee as a Habit Stack

For many of us, coffee is more than a beverage—it’s a keystone habit. It can jumpstart the day, set the tone, and even anchor other healthy behaviors like:

  • Journaling
  • Reading
  • Walking
  • Morning sunlight exposure
  • Exercise prep

So whether it’s placebo, chemical, or pure routine—if your morning coffee helps you show up better, feel sharper, and move with more intention…

Then yes, it’s good for you. Just don’t forget to hydrate, and maybe keep it to one pot—not one gallon (Lexi).

Continue reading